If you’re trying to decide what appetizers to serve before Thanksgiving dinner, these are the ones I would actually choose.
I’ve made a lot of holiday appetizers over the years, but these are the recipes I come back to again and again because they’re easy enough for a busy holiday, special enough for Thanksgiving, and the kinds of appetizers people actually eat.
Some are old-school family favorites. Some look much fancier than the work involved. And a few have become recipes my friends specifically ask me to make.
My biggest Thanksgiving appetizer rule is simple: don’t make the appetizers harder than dinner.
You already have a turkey, sides, desserts, and a million other things happening in the kitchen. I want appetizers that can be prepped ahead, assembled quickly, or kept warm without creating one more stressful project.
These are my top 10 (+ a few bonus recipes).
Thanksgiving Appetizers You Can't Get Enough Of
If regular deviled eggs feel a little predictable, these are the version I would make for Thanksgiving.
My Bloody Mary Deviled Eggs have all those savory, tangy flavors you love from a Bloody Mary, right down to the fun garnishes. They’re finished with Tajín, bacon, celery, olives, and little pickles, so they look impressive on a platter without being difficult to make.
They’re also an excellent make-ahead Thanksgiving appetizer, since you can prepare them before guests arrive and keep them chilled until serving.
If you make one appetizer for the person who loves sweet-and-savory food, make these.
Medjool dates are stuffed with goat cheese and thyme, wrapped in bacon, baked until crispy, then finished with walnuts and truffle honey.
You get sweet dates, creamy goat cheese, salty bacon, crunchy walnuts, and honey all in one bite.
Even better, you can assemble them the day before and refrigerate them until you’re ready to bake
If you have mushroom lovers coming for Thanksgiving, this is the appetizer I would make for them.
These mushroom crostini are rich and savory, with bacon and truffle honey making them taste like something you’d order at a restaurant.
They’re especially good when you want a Thanksgiving appetizer that feels a little more elevated without actually requiring complicated techniques.
This one is pure nostalgia.
Crabbies are an old-school appetizer made with crab, butter, Kraft Old English cheese spread, mayo, and seasonings spread over English muffins and baked until hot and bubbly.
They’ve been around forever for a reason.
They’re crispy, cheesy, buttery, incredibly comforting, and they remind me of the kinds of appetizers that always showed up at family holidays.
They’re also fantastic for Thanksgiving because you can assemble them ahead — even freeze them — and bake them when you’re ready.
Yes, grape jelly.
If you grew up with these, you already understand.
These grape jelly meatballs with chili sauce are sweet, savory, ridiculously easy, and made in the slow cooker.
They’re only a few ingredients, and the Crock Pot keeps them warm while everyone grazes — which makes them one of the most practical Thanksgiving appetizers on this entire list. Your current recipe is also built specifically around that easy slow-cooker method.
Adorable. Need I say more?
I try to save Ritz crackers for the holidays, and this is exactly why.
These little ham and cheese Ritz sandwiches are buttery, cheesy, bite-sized, and ridiculously easy to grab from a platter.
They’re the kind of retro appetizer people recognize immediately, and somehow the tray always disappears.
If you want an easy Thanksgiving finger food that feels nostalgic and requires very little fuss, this is it.
This is one of those recipes where a few ingredients somehow taste much more complicated than they are.
The combination of fig and blue cheese gives you sweet, salty, creamy, and tangy all in one little bite.
They look like something you’d get at a cocktail party, but they’re incredibly easy to put together — which is exactly what I want from a Thanksgiving appetizer.
Everyone loves pigs in a blanket, so why not make them look like they belong on a holiday table?
This version turns the classic appetizer into a festive wreath and finishes everything with a flavorful garlic-Parmesan butter.
It’s fun, familiar, and especially good if you have kids at Thanksgiving — although the adults will absolutely eat them too.
Everyone gets their own mini baked brie! Perfect for a crowd!
These are one of my favorite appetizers when I want the table to look beautiful without doing anything especially complicated.
The baguette slices are toasted with garlic and olive oil, then topped with creamy basil ricotta, roasted cherry tomatoes, fresh basil, and balsamic glaze.
They have that gorgeous red, white, and green look, but the flavors work just as well for Thanksgiving as they do for Christmas.
The roasted tomatoes and ricotta can be prepared ahead, which makes assembly much easier when guests arrive.
This is probably the easiest appetizer on the list.
It takes only a few ingredients, but the finished goat cheese log looks beautiful on a holiday platter.
The creamy goat cheese with sweet apricot and crunchy pecans gives you that sweet-savory combination that works so well before Thanksgiving dinner.
Serve it with crackers and you’re done.
This is exactly the kind of low-effort Thanksgiving appetizer I want when I already have an oven full of food.
My Mother-in laws recipe this is a bonus I added because they are so good I had to share them!
Which Thanksgiving Appetizers Can You Make Ahead?
If I’m hosting Thanksgiving, I want as little last-minute work as possible.
The Bloody Mary Deviled Eggs can be prepared and refrigerated ahead of time. The bacon-wrapped stuffed dates can be assembled a day before baking, and your Crabbies can be assembled up to 24 hours ahead or even frozen. Meals With Maria
The goat cheese log is another great choice because it can simply be refrigerated until you’re ready to put it out.
For crostini, I like preparing the toppings ahead and assembling closer to serving so the bread stays crisp.
And of course, the grape jelly meatballs are ideal for the slow cooker because they can stay warm while everyone arrives.
How Many Appetizers Should I Serve for Thanksgiving?
This depends on how long everyone will be hanging around before dinner.
If dinner is starting fairly soon after guests arrive, I usually think 2 to 3 appetizers is plenty.
You’re not trying to fill everyone up before the turkey.
For a longer cocktail hour or a larger group, choose 3 to 5 appetizers with different textures and flavors.
For example:
- Bloody Mary Deviled Eggs
- Bacon-Wrapped Stuffed Dates
- Grape Jelly Meatballs
- Roasted Tomato Crostini
- Pecan Apricot Goat Cheese Log
That gives you cold, warm, creamy, crunchy, meat-based, and vegetarian options without making ten separate dishes.
My Best Thanksgiving Appetizer Tip
Choose appetizers that use different parts of your kitchen.
Thanksgiving is not the day to choose four appetizers that all need the oven at the exact same time your turkey and side dishes are cooking.
A better combination might be:
- one cold appetizer
- one make-ahead appetizer
- one slow cooker appetizer
- one quick oven appetizer
That keeps your kitchen running much more smoothly.
And remember: appetizers are supposed to make hosting more enjoyable, not give you another meal to cook before the actual meal.
More Thanksgiving Recipes
Once you’ve picked your appetizers, you can finish planning your menu with my other Thanksgiving favorites:
Thanksgiving Side Dishes:
https://mealswithmaria.site/thanksgiving-side-dishes/
Thanksgiving Desserts:
https://mealswithmaria.site/thanksgiving-desserts/
Holiday Hosting Hub:
https://mealswithmaria.site/holiday-hosting-hub/
These are the kinds of holiday recipes I love most — tried-and-true dishes that feel special, but still let you enjoy the people you’re making them for.
FAQ
What are the best easy Thanksgiving appetizers?
For an easy spread, I love deviled eggs, crostini, stuffed dates, cocktail meatballs, cheese logs, and bite-sized sandwiches because many of them can be made or prepped ahead.
What appetizers can I make the day before Thanksgiving?
Deviled eggs, stuffed dates, Crabbies, cheese logs, and many crostini toppings can be prepared ahead. Keep toasted bread separate until closer to serving.
What is a good no-fuss Thanksgiving appetizer?
A goat cheese log with crackers is one of the easiest. Slow cooker grape jelly meatballs are another great choice because the Crock Pot keeps them warm without taking up oven space.
Should you serve appetizers before Thanksgiving dinner?
Yes, but keep them fairly light if dinner will be served soon. Two or three appetizers are usually enough to keep guests happy without spoiling the main meal.
Maria Ronan is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Links on this site may include affiliate links to Amazon and its affiliate sites on which the owner of this website will make a referral commission. Thank you for supporting Meals With Maria! My videos and website are for entertainment purposes only. Any information related to food, food safety, cooking, recipes, etc. are my opinions only. Maria Ronan is not liable and/or responsible for any advice, services, or product you obtain through this video and website.
Wondeful